The Cotter Pin brings urban rustic style to the Sparta area. Our menu features pizzas, wings, sandwiches, toasty Paninis, delicious soups, crispy Quesadillas and tasty wraps, which reflects our mantra of keeping it simple, and doing it well. We have a full bar, craft beers featuring regional brews, and of course an impeccable wine selection. We are located on Highway 27 just 3 miles south of Sparta in Leon, we’re close to everything but still the perfect escape. Stop in, say hello, take a look around our and stay for a while.
Classic Ham and Cheese - $9.00
Ham, cheddar cheese (may substitute any cheese). Served on ciabatta bread.
Cotter Pin Grilled Cheese - $8.00
Mozzarella and American cheese, and mayo. Served on Texas toast.
Tuna Melt - $9.50
Tuna salad, cheddar cheese, onion, and mayo.Served on ciabatta bread.
BLT - $9.00
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo, served on Texas toast.
Cotter Pin Reuben - $10.00
Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and thousand island dressing. Served on marble rye bread
French Dip - $10.50
Sliced roast beef, Swiss cheese and au jus. Served on ciabatta bread
Roast Beef & Cheddar - $10.50
Roast beef, cheddar cheese, onions, and horseradish sauce. Served on ciabatta bread.
Pulled Pork - $10.50
Shredded seasoned pork and Swiss cheese, with BBQ sauce on the side. Served on ciabatta bread.
Cuban - $12.00
Ham, pulled pork, Swiss cheese, pickle relish, mustard, and mayo. Served on ciabatta bread.
Classic Mac - $9.00
White cheddar mac and cheese.
Bacon Cheeseburger Mac - $12.50
Beef crumble, bacon crumble, red onion, and mustard.
Bacon Mac - $10.50
Bacon topping with green onion.
Wisconsin Mac - $13.50
Bratwurst, beer cheese, sauerkraut, and red onion.
Reuben Mac - $12.50
Corned beef, sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing.
Seafood Mac - $16.50
Imitation crab, shrimp, old bay seasoning, and green onion.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Mac - $12.50
Chicken, bacon, red onions, and ranch dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese - $12.50
Classic Mac & Cheese topped with Buffalo Chicken, green onions, smoky Gouda and breadcrumbs.
Cup - $3.50
Bowl - $6.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch - $9.50
Flour tortilla filled with chicken, bacon, shredded cheddar jack cheese, onions, ranch, and cheese. Served with a side of ranch and salsa.
Reuben - $9.50
Flour tortilla filled with corned beef, shredded cheddar jack cheese, sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing. Served with a side of thousand island dressing.
Buffalo Bleu - $9.50
Flour tortilla filled with chicken, shredded cheddar jack cheese, green onions, buffalo sauce, and bleu cheese. Served with a side of bleu cheese dressing (may substitute ranch dressing).
Pizza Fries - $7.50
Garlic Parmesan sauce and pizza cheese on flat bread. Served with marinara.
Cheese Chips - $7.50
Tortilla chips topped with shredded cheese. Served with a side of salsa.
Garlic Cheese Bread with Marinara - $4.50
Tots - $4.50
Seasoned tator tots. Served with sour cream.
Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese - $8.00
Spinach and Artichoke Dip - $8.50
Served with tortilla chips.
Chicken Strips - $7.50
Choice of Ranch or BBQ Sauce
Loaded Tots - $9.00
Seasoned tator tots with sausage gravy or beer cheese, bacon, shredded cheese, and green onions.
Chips and Salsa - $6.00
Potato Skins - $8.50
Baked potato skins topped with shredded cheese, green onions, and bacon. Topped with sour cream.
Nachos - $9.00
Tortilla chips, jalapeños, shredded cheese, tomatoes, black olives, green onions. Served with choice of salsa, nacho cheese, sour cream, or ranch.
Juusto - $6.50
Baked Scandinavian cheese made from local Amish farms. Choose from Italian, Garlic Parmesan, Traditional, or Jalapeno Bacon.
Pulled Pork Nachos - $13.50
Tortilla chips, jalapenos, shredded cheese, tomatoes, black olives, green onions, pulled pork, ranch. Served with choice of salsa, nacho cheese, or ranch.
Buffalo - $13.50
Tortilla chips, jalapenos, shredded cheese, tomatoes, black olives, green onions, buffalo chicken. Served with choice of salsa, nacho cheese, or ranch.
Chicken Salad - $9.50
Chicken breast, lettuce, walnuts, cranberries, celery, shredded cheese, and garlic mayo.
Chicken Bacon Ranch - $9.50
Chicken breast, shredded cheese, bacon, lettuce, onions, and ranch.
Buffalo Chicken - $9.50
Shredded chicken, lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese, buffalo sauce, and bleu cheese dressing.
Wings - $1.25/each
Served with celery and a side of ranch or bleu cheese. Quantity of at least 4 per sauce.
Boneless Wings - $8.00 for 10
Served with a choice of one sauce.
Dry Rubs Naked BBQ Sour Cream and Onion Siracha Jamaican Jerk
Wet Sauce BBQ Garlic Parmesan Buffalo Boom Boom Mango Habanero
2 Chili Cheese Hot Dogs - $9.00
Served with kettle chips and a pickle.
Burrito Boat - $9.50
Soft shell tortilla stuffed with taco meat and shredded cheese smothered in pizza sauce and more cheese! Served with choice of veggies at no cost and kettle chips, sour cream, and lettuce. Served with salsa on the side.
2 Heritage Hill Hot Dogs - $7.00
All Beef – Local
Cheese - $6.00 (Personal) / $11.50 (12") / $16.50 (16")
Pepperoni - $7.00 (Personal) / $14.00 (12") / $17.50 (16")
Sausage - $7.50 (Personal) / $14.50 (12") / $18.00 (16")
Pepperoni and Sausage - $7.50 (Personal) / $14.50 (12") / $18.00 (16")
Build Your Own Pizza! Per Veggie Option - $0.50 (Personal) / $1.00 (12") / $1.50 (16")
Options include: green pepper, onion, mushroom, pineapple, black olive, green olive, tomatoes, Jalapeño.
Build Your Own Pizza! Per Meat Topping - $1.50 (Personal) / $2.50 (12") / $3.00 (16")
Options include: bacon, ham, sausage, beef, pepperoni, chicken, buffalo chicken.
Deluxe - $15.00 (12") / $18.50 (16")
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onion, black olives, and green peppers.
Hawaiian - $17.00 (12") / $20.50 (16")
Ham, bacon, pineapple, and onion, and BBQ seasoning.
Veggie - $14.50 (12") / $18.00 (16")
Onion, green pepper, mushroom, and black olives.
Pulled Pork - $17.50 (12") / $21.50 (16")
BBQ sauce, pulled pork, relish, and onion.
4 Meat - $15.50 (12") / $19.00 (16")
Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and beef crumble.
Chili Cheese Pizza - $17.50 (12") / $21.50 (16")
Beef, bacon, chili, lettuce, chili cheese Fritos, and sour cream.
Reuben Pizza - $16.00 (12") / $19.50 (16")
Thousand island dressing, corned beef, and sauerkraut.
Garlic Chicken - $17.50 (12") / $21.50 (16")
Garlic Parmesan sauce, chicken, red onion, and tomato.
Wisconsin Octoberfest - $17.50 (12") / $21.50 (16")
Beer cheese sauce, bratwurst, sauerkraut, red onions, and BBQ seasoning.
We are looking for someone who is enthusiastic, hard working and reliable to join our team. Experience is preferred but not required. On the job, paid training and great hours. Pay is based on experience. No fryers or flat top grills. ***Must be available nights and weekends.*** Must have reliable transportation
Ask about our daily specials add check here and follow us on facebook for events and daily food and drink specials!
