Our Wines

Here is a sample of the wines available at The Cotter Pin. The wines change from time to time so this is not a complete list.

These wines are available by the glass, typically $5.00 to $6.00 per glass.


  • Pinot Grigio, DOOR PENINSULA
  • Chardonnay-Unoaked, CEDAR CREEK
  • Red Blend, 19 CRIMES (Blend)
  • Cabernet, 19 CRIMES
  • Prairie Sunburst Red, WOLLERSHEIM
  • Chambourcin, ELMARO (American Unoaked)
  • Vidal Blanc, ELMARO (American)
  • Cabernet, WALKING DEAD
  • Blood Red, WALKING DEAD (Blend)
  • Pinot Noir, MEIOMI


  • Authentic Red, GNARLY HEAD (Zinfandel)
  • Red, APOTHIC (Blend)


  • River Gold, WOLLERSHEIM (Seyval Blanc)
  • Black Cab, THREE LAKES (Cabernet, Fruit Blend)
  • Cranberry/Raspberry, THREE LAKES (Fruit)
  • Blueberry, SPURGEON (Fruit)
  • Three Cheers, ELMARO (Concord)


  • Nine Vines, ANGOVE (Moscato)
  • Blackberry, DOOR PENINSULA (Merlot)
  • Razzle Dazzle, DOOR PENINSULA (Fruit)
  • Just Peachy, FAWN CREEK (Chardonnay)
  • Black Bear-y, FAWN CREEK (Merlot)
  • Razz Prairie, FAWN CREEK (Pinot Noir)\
  • Summer Sun, FAWN CREEK (Viognier)
  • Ruby Lady, SPURGEON VINEYARDS (Table)
  • Crimson Royale, VON STIEHL (Concord)
  • Roscoto, ITALIA (Sparkling Wine)
  • Razzled, WINE SITTERS (Merlot)
  • Mosquito Moscato, LOST ISLAND
  • Sand Dollar Sangria, LOST ISLAND
  • Black Cherry Boardwalk, LOST ISLAND¬† (Pinot Noir)
  • Red Raspberry Dragon, LOST ISLAND (Pinot Noir)
  • Summer Sun, FAWN CREEK (Viognier)
  • Rosa, ELMARO (Table)


  • Tawny Port
  • Ruby Port